Hey, guys! I had to read As I Lay Dying in my English class. I had high hopes. They were crushed. Honestly, if I hadn't had to read it for school I would have abandoned it after the second chapter (it doesn't get any better).
The Cover:
The Cover:
It shows a flooded road after the large storm that knocks the bridge down, a central part of the story. However, the cover is uninteresting, just a shot of a forest. Even the other cover versions of this book aren't interesting. B- cover
Official Description:
As I Lay Dying is Faulkner's harrowing account of the Bundren family's odyssey across the Mississippi countryside to bury Addie, their wife and mother. Told in turns by each of the family members—including Addie herself—the novel ranges in mood from dark comedy to the deepest pathos.
My Review:
Usually I can find redeeming qualities in a book. That being said, I hated this book. As I Lay Dying was told in a manner that spoke more volumes of how smart the author hoped you would think he was than anything else. While I think that many classics are difficult to read, they are usually worth the hassle to understand references and feel cultured (ex. Moby Dick).
As I Lay Dying was not worth it. It is told in alternating first-person point of view, from not two, not three characters, but more than ten. It was incredibly difficult to understand who was speaking, as it was all written in first person and none of the characters were particularly distinctive. Even once you understood the characters, the chapters were more confusing than insightful. Many sentences are almost complete gibberish, even after being reread five times.
It often feels like comprehending this novel is impossible. Faulkner uses almost solely pronouns in his writing. There will be entire chapters which mention "he" and never declare who they mean.
Even when you get used to Faulkner's style of writing and mostly understand the novel, you will be disappointed. Buried underneath the symbols and confusions is... nothing worthwhile. I feel like I could read a John Green book and feel more enlightened than I did after finishing As I Lay Dying.
I honestly believe that anyone who can claim to have thoroughly enjoyed this book were lying so that you think they are cultured. Rather that or are just plain pretentious.
Don't get me wrong, I didn't hate this book just because I had trouble reading it. No. I understand this book. It's trying to prove how different people have different perspectives and about grief's varying effects. I understood this book, but I don't think that understanding is worth the pain As I Lay Dying causes by reading.
I would not recommend this book to anyone. It was just horrible. If you have to read this book for school or some other reason, I would recommend reading each chapter and then reading the Sparknotes for that chapter, so you aren't completely lost.
Phrase:
Get me some teeth
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/BookshelfSecret
The Cover:
It shows a flooded road after the large storm that knocks the bridge down, a central part of the story. However, the cover is uninteresting, just a shot of a forest. Even the other cover versions of this book aren't interesting. B- cover
Official Description:
As I Lay Dying is Faulkner's harrowing account of the Bundren family's odyssey across the Mississippi countryside to bury Addie, their wife and mother. Told in turns by each of the family members—including Addie herself—the novel ranges in mood from dark comedy to the deepest pathos.
My Review:
Usually I can find redeeming qualities in a book. That being said, I hated this book. As I Lay Dying was told in a manner that spoke more volumes of how smart the author hoped you would think he was than anything else. While I think that many classics are difficult to read, they are usually worth the hassle to understand references and feel cultured (ex. Moby Dick).
As I Lay Dying was not worth it. It is told in alternating first-person point of view, from not two, not three characters, but more than ten. It was incredibly difficult to understand who was speaking, as it was all written in first person and none of the characters were particularly distinctive. Even once you understood the characters, the chapters were more confusing than insightful. Many sentences are almost complete gibberish, even after being reread five times.
It often feels like comprehending this novel is impossible. Faulkner uses almost solely pronouns in his writing. There will be entire chapters which mention "he" and never declare who they mean.
Even when you get used to Faulkner's style of writing and mostly understand the novel, you will be disappointed. Buried underneath the symbols and confusions is... nothing worthwhile. I feel like I could read a John Green book and feel more enlightened than I did after finishing As I Lay Dying.
I honestly believe that anyone who can claim to have thoroughly enjoyed this book were lying so that you think they are cultured. Rather that or are just plain pretentious.
Don't get me wrong, I didn't hate this book just because I had trouble reading it. No. I understand this book. It's trying to prove how different people have different perspectives and about grief's varying effects. I understood this book, but I don't think that understanding is worth the pain As I Lay Dying causes by reading.
I would not recommend this book to anyone. It was just horrible. If you have to read this book for school or some other reason, I would recommend reading each chapter and then reading the Sparknotes for that chapter, so you aren't completely lost.
Phrase:
Get me some teeth
Happy Reading!
Twitter: https://twitter.com/BookshelfSecret
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/BookshelfSecret
No comments:
Post a Comment